Quick Learn

Why Do They Let Them Fight In Hockey (NHL)?

By Usha Shrestha / 24 May 2023 02:51 AM

Brendan Witt and Dan Kordic fighting in the rink on Mar 9, 1997
Source : twitter

Why do they let them fight in hockey (NHL)? They let the hockey players fight to change the results on which team makes a victory.

Ice skaters in the rink use the strategy to flourish in-game motivation, deterrence, or as an attempt to draw. In simple words, the athletes fight with the defenders to save their star fellow players from them.

Hockey is the only sports genre where players are allowed to brawl with their opponents. Other hockey leagues like Europen and the Olympics emit the offender from the rink.

On the other hand, NHL punishes those players with a penalty and suspension if the case gets serious.

In 1905, a player named Alcide Laurin passed away after opponent player Allan Loney punched and hit him in the head with a stick. Laurin was the first athlete to pass away on ice.

You May Also Like:

Slang For Penalty Box In Hockey And Other Terms Explained

5 Minute Major Penalty In Hockey Explained

What Is An Embellishment Penalty In Hockey?

Yes, fighting is legal in hockey. However, the National Hockey League is the only league to support the action.

The main reason behind it is to witness the swap of the outcome. Mostly, players feel like wrestle assists discourage rough play while creating a sense of accountability among their fellow players. 

Even if fights are permitted in the game, there are certain rules on that. The athletes should keep this in their mind once they enter the rink. Or else, they need to stay in the sin box serving the decided penalties.

If a player instigates a fight, they get a 2-minute minor penalty, a 5-minute major penalty, and a misconduct penalty of ten minutes. That makes a total of seventeen minutes of sanctions.

Fighting in Ice Hockey Rules

NHL rulebook rule number 46 depicts the fighting in Ice Hockey rules.

According to the rule, when at least one athlete punches or attempt to punch his opponent repeatedly, or two players wrestle, making it difficult for the referee to handle the situation, it is counted as fighting.

Some of the fighting rules in ice hockey are mentioned below:

  • Simple pushing and shoving in defense are acceptable. Yet, for fistfights, both playing teams are punished.
  • To fight, lineup players should drop their hockey sticks and gloves. Yet, they need to keep their helmets on.
  • The players should stop the fight when the referee orders or separates them from the opponents.
  • Athletes are permitted to combat with other players only. They can't verbally abuse the officials.
  • A major penalty is served for throwing punches with gloves removed. That makes the player sit in the punishment box for five minutes. And his team needs to continue the game with a man down.
  • "Drop The Mitts" explains the situation when a player drops his gloves and enters an altercation.
  • If the athlete from the sitting area leaves the bench to fight, the authorities can assign the player to leave the stadium instantly.

Can You Fight in College Hockey ?

No, players can't fight in college hockey.

This kind of ice hockey explains the sports played within educational institutions, mainly colleges, and universities. They practice the governance structure maintained by the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA).

College ice hockey is slightly different from the national-level league as it bans physical altercations. On the other hand, in NHL, offending ice skaters are penalized for instigating fights in ongoing games.

Avalanche players competing in the Frozen Four in April 2023
Source : twitter

In college hockey, the referee indicates the violence with a double punching motion with a fist clenched fully extended in front of the body.

According to the NCAA, rule number 48 explains the pronouncement of punching. It reads a player shall not fight an opponent or participate in a fight on or off the playing surface.

A punch thrown may be considered fighting. And the penalty for his action is disqualification. A player who starts the altercation receives an additional penalty for instigating a fight.

When the official orders the player to stop his violent action, he must obey the order and shall not continue an altercation.

Is Fighting Allowed in Olympic Ice Hockey?

No, Olympic ice hockey strictly prohibits fighting.

Similarly, European professional hockey leagues such as English Premier Ice Hockey, Hockey Europe, Deutsche Eishockey Liga, Metal Ligaen, and some others discourage this kind of action.

The Olympics winter game and international leagues banned the action to ensure fair competition among the players. That is the main reason. Also, these leagues guarantee to protect the ice skaters from getting wounded due to violence.

So, what if brawling breaks out?

If a player is caught fighting during an Olympic match, his team loses the points or ends the game. In the worst-case scenario, they get disqualified from the competition altogether.

The Canadiens, Olympic Women's ice hockey champions 2022
Source : twitter

Thus, audiences and athletes can ensure there won't be any fights on the rink.  Ice skaters are aware that their team may no longer be eligible to compete in remaining games if they practice altercations with the opponent team.

So, there is less violence in the Olympics compared to traditional ice hockey.

Fighting in World Junior Hockey

Fighting in world junior hockey is not allowed. Minor hockey and youth hockey programs discourage any form of scrimmage.

The action is considered the third main reason behind the players getting hurt. The first two are a player hitting the board or the wall and errant body parts.

Even though fistfight is prohibited the World Juniors had an incident of brawl. On January 4, 1987, Canada and the Soviet Union teams were ejected from the final game.

The International Ice Hockey Federation suspended the players of both teams for 18 months and the mentors for three years. Several players were allowed to play after the reduction of the sanction to six months.

Longest And Biggest NHL Fight in History

The longest and biggest NHL fight in history spells out the Wachovia Center game on March 5, 2004. Philadelphia Flyers and Ottawa Senators were the playing teams.

Matthew Barnaby brawling with his opponent player
Source : twitter

The brawl between the Flyers and the Senators broke the previous record of 406 minutes of penalty time. In the game, 419 minutes of penalty were assessed, out of which the Flyers served 213 minutes altogether.

The incident was the precipitation of the previous game, where Martin Havlat dangled his hockey stick at Mark Recchi's head. Donald Brashear, Rob Ray, Robert Esche, Patrick Lalime, Jason Spezza, and Patrick Sharp were involved in the brawling.

The Flyers won the match 5-3.

10 Best Fighters in NHL

The scuffle has been a part of ice hockey since its beginning phase. however, not all athletes fight intentionally.

They aim to save their star players from the opponent attackers. Some big guys in the league can fight with anyone. Some of them from the past years are Bob Probert, Dave Schultz, Dave Williams, Tie Domi, and others.

10 best fighters in NHL 2022-2023 season are as follows. Together, their team and total fights are also mentioned:

  1. Nicolas Deslauriers, Philadelphia Flyers -14 Fights
  2. Patrick Marron, Tampa Bay Lightning -12 Fights
  3. Austin Watson, Ottawa Senators -12 Fights
  4. Tanner Jeannot, Tampa Bay Lightning - 11 Fights
  5. Jonah Gadjovich, San Jose Sharks - 9 Fights
  6. Mathieu Olivier, Columbus Blue Jackets - 9 Fights
  7. Corey Perry, Tampa Bay Lightning - 9 Fights
  8. Michael Pezzetta, Montreal Canadiens - 9 Fights
  9. Arber Xhekaj, Montreal Canadiens - 9 Fights
  10. Kyle Burroughs, Vancouver Canucks - 8 Fights

Should Fighting Be Allowed in Hockey: Pros and Cons

Fighting should be allowed in hockey to make the sport safer. It makes the rosters more accountable.

The fight ratio has slackened comparing the regular season each year. In the 2000-2001 season, the calculation was up to 40%, while the number decreased in 2013-2014 by 27%.

Likewise, the proportion reduced to 17% by the end of the 2018-2019 season. 86 fights were registered in the season out of 460 games.

Every system and rule has positive and negative sides. Here, we discuss the ice hockey brawl.

Pros

  • Players can save their leading men from the offensive opponents
  • Brawling increases the entertainment value of the game
  • Fans enjoy the match with full attention

Cons

  • It can be a bad example for the kids watching fights at a professional level
  • Brawls in sports lead to mental and physical harm 

Ice hockey Is the National Game of Which Country?

Ice hockey is the national game of Canada. Latvia also has ice hockey as its national sport.

According to the National Sports of Canada Act 1994, ice hockey became the national winter sport, while lacrosse became the civic sport for summer.

The Canadiens played a one-man less game on April 14
Source : instagram

The sport is known as hockey in North America and parts of Europe. British soldiers brought sticks and balls to play in the ice and snow on the North American continent between the 1850s and 1860s.

The systematic ice skating game was first played indoors on March 3, 1875, in Montreal, Quebec. They used a rubber puck to have a match between two teams with nine members each.

Later in 1917, the professional ice hockey league was founded with four Canadian teams, including the Montreal Canadiens, Ottawa Senators, Toronto, and Quebec Bulldogs.

At present, the league has 32 franchises and is divided into the preseason, regular season, and postseason. Not to forget, the Montreal Canadiens is the country with the highest Stanley Cup Championship with 24 times victory.